Print vs. Film: Enemies or Friends?

Share on Pinterest
Share this post via email










Submit

In his 1985 book Amusing Ourselves to Death the late Neil Postman declared the demise of the Age of Exposition and the rise of the Age of Entertainment. He offered sober warnings about the decline of the written word and the rise of images and sounds.

Whether we like it or not, the medium of film is a powerful cultural force. Motion pictures, television, online videos, and even video on demand on smartphones are realities of our world. But how do they relate to homeschooling? Before we get there, let's look at some differences between print and film.

Are there differences between print and film? Of course. They are different mediums. Print, for instance, is mostly conceptual, dealing with linear ideas. Film, on the other hand, is mostly visual, dealing with images that may or may not be linear. Print typically requires concentrated thought, while film generally requires little concentrated thought. Print excels in building rational arguments, but film favors entertainment over rigorous rational discourse. Print requires literacy, while film generally does not. Print is usually a quiet endeavor, involving an interplay between the author and reader. Film, though, is noisy, involving sounds, music, etc. Print records the great ideas of human history, while film is mostly transient and fleeting (especially much television). Finally, we could say print is active, while film is passive. That is to say, if we are good readers we engage printed ideas actively, but when we watch film we are mostly passive observers. There are exceptions to each of these points, but on the whole I believe these differences are representative of what is typical of each medium.

With that said, we could also add that print and film share some similarities. Both, for example, can tell a story, evoke emotions, share ideas, entertain, can be artistic, and are capable of communicating truth or error.

Must print and film engage in battle? Not necessarily. Film can often serve as an engaging supplement or complement to literature-rich homeschooling pursuits. After all, it's one thing to read about something and another to see it in action. With parental monitoring sites like YouTube offer a wealth of educational supplements that will excite your children and move them to want to learn more about various subjects. This is one reason Sonlight incorporated links to video clips in many of our Sonlight Science programs a few years ago.

I've written elsewhere that film is the "new literature." I don't mean that literature will disappear, but that we've largely shifted from a culture that asks, "Have you read?" to "Have you seen?"

Sonlight is literature rich. We value the written word and the ability of literature-based stories to make a difference in lives, whether it's shaping character, exposing us to different cultural ideas, or just entertaining us with characters that come to life. Understanding the differences between film and print can help us better understand these mediums, as well as how to better incorporate them in our efforts to educate our children.

Do you incorporate video when you teach your children? Let us know how you do it and how your children respond.

Robert Velarde
Author/Educator/Philosopher

More Sonlight Articles
Filter by
Post Page
Robert
Sort by
Share on Pinterest
Share this post via email










Submit
Robert

About Robert

Robert Velarde serves as a curriculum creator with Sonlight's product development team. He’s author of The Wisdom of Pixar, A Visual Defense, Conversations with C.S. Lewis, The Golden Rules of Narnia, and more.
Posted in: Robert Tags: , , , , , , ,
Link to this post.

2 Responses to Print vs. Film: Enemies or Friends?

  1. Stephanie G says:

    We use film to reinforce ideas we have read and studied. It brings it to life - in a very different way than one can imagine. If you are learning about Lions and you see pictures of lions and read about them - it still doesn't help you to grasp being able to see a lion and hear it and watch it move. Film can do that when the option to go see a real life lion isn't available. We often use youtube to bring to life things my children cannot fully grasp through just print. We use full lenght films to do the same - how can one really know and grasp "space". Pictures and the written word can begin the understanding - but watching a movie - like Apollo 13 or videos of astronauts in space- brings to life the reality my children otherwise might not experience. Film should be used to bring about the deeper dimension of learning and experiencing - not to replace print.

  2. Robert Robert says:

    Thanks for the comment, Stephanie. It sounds like you have worked out a good way to incorporate video into your homeschooling!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Time limit is exhausted. Please reload CAPTCHA.