Just Because We Want It

Share on Pinterest
There are no images.
Share this post via email










Submit

...doesn't mean we want it.

There are loaded statements just as there are loaded questions. For instance, it is unfair to ask, "Have you stopped beating your wife?" In fact, the answer may be:


Mu taken from Wikipedia

But with loaded statements, sometimes it's harder to have a good answer like a single, cool-looking Japanese character. Two posts got me thinking about this today, one by Jessica and the other by Karen.

The first loaded statement is "you should give back to the community." Is anyone mean enough to say, "Oh no, I don't want to give back." But who readily gives back? Well, those of us who like to share what we've learned. But, as Jessica points out, you can't give back something that you earned--that's just simple, charitable giving... not "giving back."

Along the same lines, Karen (Spunky) points out that no one doesn't want children everywhere to have a "decent education." The problem arises when people fail to define what a "decent education" is. As it stands, that phrase means very different things to people. Until we decide on a clear definition of that statement, I don't think anyone should agree that we should push for everyone to get a "decent" education.

So, like loaded questions, loaded statements would disappear with more clarification, definition, and quick discussion. Otherwise people are likely to say, "We want that," but then wonder why they didn't get what they wanted when it comes about.

If you're looking for a fun extra topic to start introducing, fallacies could be a fun one. Your students will certainly need that knowledge in the future.

~Luke Holzmann
Filmmaker, Writer, Expectant Father

Share on Pinterest
There are no images.
Share this post via email










Submit

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Time limit is exhausted. Please reload CAPTCHA.

3 Comments

  1. Craig and Heather

    This is so true!

    And I'm laughing because when my 10 YO daughter was two and a half, she sassily told me "I want what I want".

    Curious as to what it was she wanted, I asked "Oh yeah, what do you want?"

    And without skipping a beat, she said "I have NO idea!"

  2. agentlejoy

    I think you're a terrific encourager- and I am continually blessed by your little visits to my blog. Makes me feel like I'm hosting a visiting celebrity.

    I posted a long comment to your post on abortion, but I think I forgot to do the word verification, and, well... the computer ate my comment.

    But keep writing- you have a lot of great things to say for a man who once pulled his sweat-pants string over his head and has holes in his shoes.

    May God bless you & your wife & your future child,
    A

  3. Luke

    Heather,

    That's hilarious! Love it. <smile>

    Angela,

    I'm honored to be considered a celebrity, but I'm really just a average abnormal guy <grin>.

    It is nice to hear that I am encouraging. Sometimes you post comments and wonder if people take them right. I'm afraid someday someone is going to be horribly bothered by one of my comments. So far, so good <smile>.

    Bummer about your comment getting eaten. I would have loved to hear your thoughts!

    Thanks so much for stopping by, both of you. I love comments! (who doesn't? <smile>)

    ~Luke